Historic human rights ruling: Alberta tribunal sets record with landmark damages award, redefining the rules on compensation and deterrence
John A.C. Morse and Lauren Sorel
The Human Rights Tribunal of Alberta (the “Tribunal”) recently awarded three complainants a total of $273,274.91 in compensation, with $155,000.00 of this amount designated as general damages – a new record in Canadian human rights law. This landmark decision not only raises the bar for compensation but also underscores the importance of deterrence against discriminatory actions, particularly those related to sexual and gender-based discrimination.
Case Overview: Oliva, Pascoe, and Strong v. Gursoy, 2024 AHRC 45
This case involved three female employees (Oliva, Pascoe, and Strong) of TJ Construction Management Ltd. (“TJCM”), each of whom left their positions after being subjected to severe sexual harassment and discrimination based on gender and physical disability by their boss, Gursoy.
- Oliva was employed by TJCM for just over one year. She experienced various instances of sexual harassment and gender-based discrimination due to inappropriate comments, touching, and requests from Gursoy. Additionally, the Tribunal found that Gursoy engaged in discrimination based on physical disability by demanding details of a medical diagnosis that were irrelevant to Olivia’s employment.
- Pascoe worked with TJCM for approximately one month. Her complaint mirrored Oliva’s, involving inappropriate sexual comments, advances, and touching by Gursoy.
- Strong, the third employee, worked for TJCM for approximately eight months. She was also subjected to inappropriate touching and suggestions by Gursoy and faced additional mistreatment, including being berated and demoted due to her pregnancy.
Each of the complaints was upheld despite being untested by the Respondent and based solely on documentary evidence and hearing submissions, as Gursoy was removed from the proceedings for his “refusal to treat the complaints with civility and respect.”
While the general damages were distributed among the complainants, the $75,000.00 awarded to Oliva is the highest individual award of general damages in the human rights context. The substantial award in this case was supported by the finding that Gursoy’s conduct was “deserving of denunciation” and had severe impacts on each complainant, particularly Oliva, who suffered from depression as a result of her employment with TJCM.
In a separate decision, the Tribunal awarded significant costs related to these proceedings, granting each complainant $10,000 despite no evidence of substantial legal fees incurred. The Tribunal deemed a costs award appropriate due to Gursoy’s “constantly egregious behaviour.”
Implications
This decision signifies a shift toward using general damages not only for compensation but also as a punitive measure to deter serious discriminatory behaviour. Employers must now be more vigilant in preventing and addressing such misconduct to avoid substantial penalties. Proactive measures include maintaining a safe work environment, implementing clear anti-discrimination policies, conducting fair investigations, and seeking legal advice early.
This client update is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you have any questions about the above, please contact a member of our Labour and Employment Group.
Click here to subscribe to Stewart McKelvey Thought Leadership.
Archive
IN THIS ISSUE: 10 Things employers need to know about employing temporary foreign workers by Andrea Baldwin, Michelle McCann and Sean Kelly. Landlords’ protection from mechanic’ (builders’) liens by Hugh Cameron and Lara MacDougall. The new Canada not-for-profit Corporations Act by Alanna Waberski, Sarah Almon and Kimberly Bungay. Download…
Read MoreOn January 31, 2014, The Office of the Superintendent of Insurance issued a bulletin in Nova Scotia. For 2014, the Minor Injury Cap for Nova Scotia is $8,213. This is a 1.4 per cent increase…
Read MoreIn the Federal Budget 2011, the Government of Canada stated that it would develop a new plan to support public infrastructure beyond the expiry of the 2007 Building Canada Plan in 2013-14. The Government has…
Read MoreCASL is a new federal law aimed at eliminating unsolicited and malicious electronic communications. Originally introduced in December 2010, the majority of CASL’s provisions will come into force on July 1, 2014. Once in effect,…
Read MoreThe Termination Meeting: A time and a place for everything The decision has been made, but the ship hasn’t yet sailed. Somebody has to deliver the bad news and as difficult as this might be,…
Read MoreClient Update: Consistent Use: The Collection of Union Members’ Personal Information by their Unions
The Public Service Labour Relations Board concluded that an employer was required to provide home contact information about bargaining unit members to the union which represents them because this information is needed by the union…
Read MoreIn preparing for the 2014 proxy season, you should be aware of some regulatory changes that may impact disclosure to and interactions with your shareholders. This update highlights what is new in the 2014 proxy…
Read MoreIn a decision released by the Supreme Court of Canada (“the Court”) on January 31, 2014, the Court clarified the law with respect to the tort of interference with economic relations by unlawful means. Joyce,…
Read MoreAs we move into 2014, we know our region’s employers will want to be aware of new legislation that has passed or could soon pass that may affect them. The following is what has become…
Read MoreWhat’s new? Our employer clients will be familiar with the Labour Standards Act, which sets out the employment standards applicable in Newfoundland and Labrador. Two amendments were made to the legislation this week, both of which…
Read More