Skip to content

An email scam cautionary tale

By Nancy Rubin, K.C. and Levi Parsche

What happens if a person accidentally makes payment to a hacker, instead of to the person they actually owe money? Should they have to pay again? In the recent decision, Jane Group Limited v. Heritage Gas Limited, 2022 NSSM 36, a small claims court adjudicator said yes.

EFT Payment Scam

In the case, two companies had agreed to split the costs to repair a sidewalk after a natural gas line was installed. Shortly after the repairs were completed, Jane Group emailed Heritage Gas seeking payment of its share. Heritage Gas responded, requesting an invoice for the repairs, and indicated it could pay by electronic funds transfer (“EFT”) or via cheque. So far, so good.

Then, Heritage Gas received what it assumed was a response from Jane Group, providing banking information and instructions to send payment via EFT. Unfortunately, this email was actually from an online hacker who had intercepted previous communications. The hacker, representing themselves as the Jane Group president, provided information for a fraudulent bank account, and asked for the money to be deposited that same day.

Heritage Gas emailed Jane Group again indicating it needed an invoice before it could make a payment. In response, (and from a different email address) Jane Group provided an invoice, which indicated payment should be made by cheque to a mailing address.

Unfortunately, upon receipt of the invoice, Heritage Gas followed the earlier EFT instructions that had been sent, depositing the payment into the fraudulent bank account provided by the hacker.

Decision

Having not received payment, Jane Group sued for recovery from Heritage Gas.  Counsel for Jane Group argued that there were several “red flags” in the email from the hacker (spacing and typographical errors) which should have triggered a follow-up by Heritage Gas, not to mention the discrepancy in the direction to pay via EFT or cheque.

On the other hand, counsel for Heritage Gas argued that the loss of money was due to Jane Group’s “carelessness” and lack of cybersecurity.

In the end, Adjudicator Darling found that both parties were innocent victims of the hacker and ruled that as neither party had exhibited blameworthy conduct, the case must be decided in favour of the Claimant, Jane Group.

Key Takeaway

As we move towards an increasingly digital world, this case serves as a reminder to keep an eye out for fraudulent activity. Take extra steps to make sure your electronic funds transfers are secure.  Watch out for email red flags (typos, suspicious links, misspellings, a sense of urgency) and confirm payment details via an additional method – otherwise you might end up on the hook and have to pay twice!


This update is intended for general information only. If you have questions about the above, please contact the authors.

Click here to subscribe to Stewart McKelvey Thought Leadership.

SHARE

Archive

Search Archive


 
 

Attract & Retain: Nova Scotia taps foreign healthcare workers to fill labour shortages

November 10, 2022

As part our presenting sponsorship of the Halifax Chamber of Commerce’s Annual Fall Dinner, we are pleased to present a series of thought leadership articles highlighting the dinner’s themes of immigration, recruitment, and labour market…

Read More

The rise of remote work and Canadian immigration considerations

November 3, 2022

As part our presenting sponsorship of the Halifax Chamber of Commerce’s Annual Fall Dinner, we are pleased to present a series of thought leadership articles highlighting the dinner’s themes of immigration, recruitment, and labour market…

Read More

The future of express entry: Targeted draws to meet Canada’s economic needs

November 2, 2022

By Sara Espinal Henao Since its initial launch in January 2015, Express Entry has been a pillar of Canada’s immigration system. Recently passed amendments to the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) promise to drive…

Read More

Filling labour gaps with foreign workers: What Canadian employers need to know

October 28, 2022

By Brittany Trafford It is no secret that employers in Atlantic Canada are struggling to fill labour gaps. In June 2019 the Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency (ACOA) published a report[1] indicating that the overall labour…

Read More

Updated employer compliance requirements for employers of foreign workers

October 26, 2022

This article was updated on May 4, 2023. By Brendan Sheridan The Government of Canada has recently taken steps to further protect foreign workers employed in Canada. These efforts by the government have, in some…

Read More

Nova Scotia setting legislative framework for green hydrogen

October 24, 2022

Sadira Jan, Dave Randell, and James Gamblin On October 17, 2022, the Government of Nova Scotia tabled bills that would amend four pieces of legislation in support of future green hydrogen development. The intended impacts…

Read More

Newfoundland and Labrador Introduces Pay Equity & Transparency Law

October 20, 2022

By Ruth Trask  and Josh Merrigan Pay equity is an increasing focus for governments and advocates in the employment world, which means that employers must also pay attention. The Government of Newfoundland and Labrador has…

Read More

Upcoming changes for international students in Canada

October 12, 2022

By Kathleen Leighton Canada is facing considerable labour shortages resulting from a myriad of factors including its aging population and declining birth rates. As a result, our immigration strategy going forward must help drive the…

Read More

New Brunswick Provincial Government releases Climate Change Plan

October 11, 2022

By Alanna Waberski and Isaac McLellan On September 21, 2022, the Government of New Brunswick released its renewed climate change action plan which aims to help the province adapt to climate change while steering New…

Read More

Court upholds mandatory vaccine policy – Placing employee on unpaid leave not constructive dismissal

October 3, 2022

Mark Tector and Ben Currie While there have been a number of arbitration decisions on the subject, Parmar v Tribe Management Inc., 2022 BCSC 1675 appears to be the first reported civil court decision to…

Read More

Search Archive


Scroll To Top