Skip to Content

Recent case re-confirms temporary ailment is not a disability

By Mark Tector and Tiegan A. Scott

Decision

On April 3, 2024, the Alberta Court of King’s Bench (“ABKB”) upheld a decision of the Chief of the Commissions and Tribunals (the “CCT Decision”), which held that the common flu is not a recognized disability under the Alberta Human Rights Act.  This decision is consistent with cases from the rest of Canada, including from the Supreme Court of Canada.

In Smith v Alberta (Alberta Human Rights Commission)[1], an employee called in sick, then took the next three days off without giving notice to their employer. This contravened the employer’s absenteeism policy. The employee asserted that he was suffering from a severe flu, which he claimed was a protected disability under the provincial Human Rights Act.

The employee applied to the CCT alleging the employer’s policy resulted in adverse treatment on the grounds of physical disability. The Complaint was dismissed, and the employee appealed to the ABKB.

Upholding the CCT Decision, the ABKB reasoned that a disability is more than a common and temporary ailment. Here, the employee’s flu lasted less than a week. The ABKB also dismissed the employee’s argument that two pre-existing injuries (one of which was sustained at work), in conjunction with the flu, created a disability.

And, as more good news for employers, the ABKB found the employee had been properly accommodated for an ankle injury that had occurred in the workplace. The employer acted reasonably in altering the employee’s duties (i.e. placing him on forklift duty), even though the employee viewed the accommodations as a demotion. Because the employee’s illness (i.e. flu) was not a disability, the employer had no duty to accommodate the employee regarding compliance with the absenteeism policy.

Applicability to Atlantic Canada

The principles in Smith are good law in Atlantic Canada. As with any situation involving employee disabilities or claims for accommodation, each case will need to be considered on its own facts.  However, all four Atlantic provinces have released provincial guidelines to the effect that flus, colds, or other common and temporary ailments will, in most cases, not qualify as a disability.[2]

Key takeaways for employers:

  • Recognized disabilities under Human Rights Legislation are more than a common and transitory sickness such as the common cold or flu.
  • However, simply because an illness is transitory does not automatically disqualify it as a disability. Rather, employers must be cautious and assess the claim on a case-by-case basis.
  • Accommodation does not have to be perfect, just reasonable in the particular circumstances.
  • Just as employers have a duty to accommodate employees, employees have a duty to cooperate and comply with the accommodations provided to them by their employer.

Employers are encouraged to reach out to our labour and employment team with any questions regarding employee disability claims. We are always available to answer any questions on what steps employers can take in a specific case, and help you decide on the right strategic approach to respond to the issues raised.


This client update is provided for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. If you have any questions about the above, please contact the authors, or a member of our Labour & Employment Group.

Click here to subscribe to Stewart McKelvey Thought Leadership.

[1] 2024 ABKB 187 (CanLII), [Smith].
[2] Newfoundland, PEI, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia

Archive

Making AI work for your business

Sarah Dever Letson and Lauren Agnew Interested in understanding the impacts of AI on your business? Looking to understand how these intersect with concerns around privacy and cybersecurity? Curious about…

Read More

Navigating the “Towns Act”: Key changes and transition considerations for towns in Newfoundland and Labrador

BY Stephen Penney & Danielle Harris

By Stephen Penney and Danielle Harris Introduction On January 1, 2025, the Towns and Local Service Districts Act (the “Towns Act”) came into effect, changing the legislative landscape for towns…

Read More

Dealing with Canadian “retaliatory” tariffs: A primer for importers

BY Michelle Chai & Graeme Hiebert

By Michelle Chai & Graeme Hiebert In response to the 25% tariffs levied on virtually all Canadian goods by the United States, Canada has announced United States Surtax Order (2025-1)…

Read More

Balancing inclusivity and workplace safety

BY Sheila Mecking & Lauren Sorel

By Sheila Mecking and Lauren Sorel Introduction Arbitrator Trisha Perry addressed the complex interests between inclusive education and workplace safety in a recent decision (New Brunswick Teachers’ Federation v New…

Read More

University governance in Nova Scotia: The impacts of Bill 12

BY Colleen Keyes,
K.C.
& Harper Metler

By Colleen Keyes, K.C. and Harper Metler On February 19, 2025, the Nova Scotia Government introduced Bill No. 12: An Act Respecting Advanced Education and Research (“Bill 12”), which is…

Read More

Privacy rights in the workplace: Supreme Court expands charter protections for public school teachers

BY Chad Sullivan & Chiara Nannucci

By Chad Sullivan and Chiara Nannucci Introduction A recent Supreme Court of Canada decision (York Region District School Board v. Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario, 2024 SCC 22) has once…

Read More

New rules allowing Nova Scotia private sector employers to join Public Service Superannuation Plan take effect

BY Dante Manna & Noah Archibald

By Dante Manna and Noah Archibald The Provincial Government recently proclaimed the Private Sector Pension Plan Transfer Act (the “Transfer Act”) and newly released regulations on February 4, 2025. The…

Read More

Outlook for 2025 proxy season

By Andrew V. Burke, Colleen P. Keyes, Gavin Stuttard, David F. Slipp and Logan G. Walters With proxy season on the horizon, many public companies are once again preparing their…

Read More

Here we go again … how recent updates to Canada’s supply chain transparency reporting guidance may impact your 2025 reporting obligations

By Christine Pound, Colleen Keyes, K.C., and Daniel Roth As reporting entities and government institutions prepare their supply chain transparency reports, Public Safety Canada (“PSC“) has updated its guidance for…

Read More

Energy Watch 2025

Stewart McKelvey is pleased to present Energy Watch – a review of key legislative and policy advancements in the renewable energy sector in 2024 in Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick and a look forward to anticipated activities in 2025.

Read More

Search Archive